The rolling pin can successfully strike about 667 times from full condition before breaking. Due to its much higher base damage of 20, the simulation version can only successfully strike about 100 times before breaking.
A special version exists in the simulation Tranquility Lane, with significantly higher damage. It is found on the kitchen table in the Rockwell Residence. Killing anyone in Tranquility Lane is temporary, as talking to Betty will reset them. If you activate the Chinese invasion simulator, they will stop reseting.