- .45 Auto pistol Honest Hearts, the standard version found throughout Zion Canyon.
- A Light Shining in Darkness Honest Hearts, a unique, customized pistol used by Joshua Graham.
- Joshua's Pistol Whippin' .45 Honest Hearts, is a unique non-playable variant used by Joshua Graham. It differs from A Light Shining in Darkness by being used as a melee weapon.
- This version is carried by Follows-Chalk and it can only be obtained by using console commands.